Module 2.6  Retrieving Memories861

Module 2.6 Retrieving Memories

LT

2.6-1 Explain how external cues, internal emotions, and order of appearance influence memory retrieval.

2.6-2 Explain how retrieval practice strategies, such as the testing effect, interleaving, and metacognition, support memory retrieval.

After the magic of our brain’s encoding and storage, we still have the daunting task of retrieving the information. Accessing stored memories involves either recall — our ability to produce previously learned information — or recognition — our ability to identify previously learned items. (See Module 2.3 for more on recall and recognition.)

For stored information to be retrieved and processed, it must migrate from long-term memory storage into working memory — like taking out a box stored in a closet. Once it’s in our working memory, the box can be opened, and its contents can enter our consciousness. So, what triggers retrieval, and what strategies can we use to improve our retrieval?

Retrieval Cues

2.6-1 How do external cues, internal emotions, and order of appearance influence memory retrieval?

862

Imagine a spider suspended in the middle of her web, held up by the many strands extending outward from her in all directions to different points. If you were to trace a pathway to the spider, you would first need to locate an anchor point and then follow the strand into the web.

The process of retrieving a memory follows a similar principle. Within our semantic networks, memories are held in storage by a web of associations, each piece of information interconnected with others. When you encode into memory a target piece of information, such as the name of the person sitting next to you in class, you associate with it other bits of information about your surroundings, mood, seating position, and so on. These bits can serve as retrieval cues — like passwords that open memories. The more retrieval cues you have, the better your chances of finding a route to the suspended memory. The best retrieval cues come from associations we form when we encode a memory — smells, tastes, and sights that can evoke our memory of the associated person or event (Tamminen & Mebude, 2019). “Memory is not like a container that gradually fills up; it is more like a tree growing hooks onto which memories are hung” (Russell, 1979).

We need to retrieve memories for both our past (called retrospective memory) and our intended future actions (called prospective memory). To remember to do something (say, to text someone before you go out), one effective strategy is to mentally associate the act with a cue (perhaps putting your phone by the door) (Rogers & Milkman, 2016). It pays to plan ahead, which helps explain why most people spend more time thinking about their future than about their past (Anderson & McDaniel, 2019).

Does the unprepared astronaut illustrate a failure of retrospective or prospective memory?6

Priming

Often our associations are activated without our awareness. Philosopher-psychologist William James referred to this process, which we call priming, as the “wakening of associations.” After seeing or hearing the word rabbit, we are later more likely to spell the spoken word hair/hare as h-a-r-e, even if we don’t recall seeing or hearing rabbit (Bower, 1986) (Figure 2.6-1).

priming
the activation, often unconsciously, of particular associations in memory.

863
hair or hare? h-a-i-r h-a-r-e

Figure 2.6-1 Priming associations unconsciously activates related associations

AP® Science Practice  |  Research

To address the question “Does priming affect recall?”, researchers must use experimental methods. Experimental methods allow for cause-effect conclusions. You can review which research methods are best suited for various types of research questions in Module 0.4.

Priming is often “memoryless memory” — an implicit, invisible memory, without your conscious awareness. If you see a poster of a missing child, you may then unconsciously be primed to interpret an ambiguous adult-child interaction as a possible kidnapping (James, 1986). Although you no longer have the poster in mind, it predisposes your decision-making. Priming can also influence behaviors (Weingarten et al., 2016). Adults and children primed with money-related words and materials change their behavior in various ways, such as by becoming less helpful (Gasiorowska et al., 2016; Lodder et al., 2019). Money may prime our materialism and self-interest.

864

TRY THIS

Ask a friend three rapid-fire questions:

  1. What color is the snow?
  2. What color are clouds?
  3. What do cows drink?

If your friend answers “milk” to the third question, you have demonstrated priming.

Context-Dependent Memory

Have you noticed that putting yourself back in the context where you experienced something earlier can prime your memory retrieval? Remembering, in many ways, depends on our environment (Palmer, 1989). When you visit your childhood home or neighborhood, old memories surface. When scuba divers listened to a word list in one of two different settings (either 10 feet underwater or sitting on the beach), they recalled more words when later tested in the same place where they first heard the list (Godden & Baddeley, 1975).

By contrast, experiencing something outside the usual setting can be confusing. Have you ever run into a former teacher in an unusual place, such as at a store or in a park? Perhaps you felt a glimmer of recognition, but struggled to realize who it was and how you were acquainted. The encoding specificity principle helps us understand how specific cues will most effectively trigger that memory. In new settings, you may be missing the memory cues needed for speedy face recognition. Our memories are context-dependent, and are affected by the cues we have associated with that context.

865

encoding specificity principle
the idea that cues and contexts specific to a particular memory will be most effective in helping us recall it.

In several studies, Carolyn Rovee-Collier (1993) found that a familiar context activated memories even in 3-month-olds. After infants learned that kicking would make a crib mobile move (via a connecting ribbon from their ankle), the infants kicked more when tested again in the same crib than when in a different context.

State-Dependent Memory

Closely related to context-dependent memory is state-dependent memory. What we learn in one state may be more easily recalled when we are again in that state. What adults learn when drunk they don’t recall well in any state (alcohol disrupts memory storage). But they recall it slightly better when again drunk. Adults who hide money when drunk may forget the location until drunk again.

866

Moods also provide an example of memory’s state dependence. Emotions that accompany good or bad events become retrieval cues (Gaddy & Ingram, 2014). Thus, our memories are somewhat mood congruent. If you’ve had a bad day — you argued with a friend, lost your phone, and got a poor grade on your midterm — your gloomy mood may facilitate recalling other bad times. Depression sours memories by priming negative associations, which we then use to explain our current mood (Mihailova & Jobson, 2020). In many studies, people put in a happy mood — whether under hypnosis or just by the day’s events (a World Cup soccer victory for German participants in one study) — recall the world through rose-colored glasses (DeSteno et al., 2000; Forgas et al., 1984; Schwarz et al., 1987). They recall their behaviors as competent and effective, other people as benevolent, and happy events as more frequent.

mood-congruent memory
the tendency to recall experiences that are consistent with one’s current good or bad mood.

867

Have you ever noticed that your current mood influences your perceptions of others? In one study, adolescents’ ratings of parental warmth in one week gave little clue to how they would rate their parents 6 weeks later (Bornstein et al., 1991). When teens were down, their parents seemed cruel; as their mood brightened, their parents morphed from devils into angels. And at age 26, people’s recall of their parents’ caregiving during their childhood was linked less with the actual caregiving (which had been assessed years earlier) than with their current moods and parental relationship (Nivison et al., 2021). Moods modify memories.

We may nod our heads knowingly. Yet, while in a good or bad mood, we persist in attributing to reality our own changing judgments, memories, and interpretations. While in a bad mood, we may read someone’s look as a glare and feel even worse. While in a good mood, we may encode the same look as interest and feel even better. Moods magnify.

Mood effects on retrieval help explain why our moods persist. When happy, we recall pleasant events and see the world as a wonderful place, which helps prolong our good mood. When depressed, we recall sad events, which darkens our interpretations of current events. For those of us predisposed to depression, this process can help maintain a vicious, dark cycle.

868

Serial Position Effect

Another memory-retrieval quirk, the serial position effect, explains why we may have large holes in our memory of a list of recent events. Imagine it’s your first day in a new job, and your manager is introducing you to your co-workers. As you meet each person, you silently repeat everyone’s name, starting from the beginning. As the last person smiles and turns away, you feel confident you’ll be able to greet your new co-workers by name the next day.

serial position effect
our tendency to recall best the last items in a list initially (a recency effect), and the first items in a list after a delay (a primacy effect).

Don’t count on it. Because you have spent more time rehearsing the earlier names than the later ones, those are the names you’ll probably recall more easily the next day. In studies, when people viewed a list of items (words, names, dates) and then immediately tried to recall them in any order, they fell prey to the serial position effect (Daniel & Katz, 2018; Dimsdale-Zucker et al., 2019). They briefly recalled the last items especially quickly and well (a recency effect), perhaps because those items were still in working memory. But after a delay, when their attention was elsewhere, their recall was best for the first items (a primacy effect; see Figure 2.6-2).

869
THE ACADEMY AWARDS 2019

Figure 2.6-2 The serial position effect

Immediately after Mahershala Ali made his way down the red carpet at the 2019 Academy Awards, he would probably have best recalled the names of the last few people he greeted (recency effect). But later, he may have been able to recall the first few people best (primacy effect).

Retrieval Practice Strategies

2.6-2 How do retrieval practice strategies, such as the testing effect, interleaving, and metacognition, support memory retrieval?

870

So, how can we improve our memory retrieval? Psychology’s research has uncovered several effective strategies, including:

Metacognition. As we saw in Module 2.2, it pays to think about our thinking! Students who use metacognition — who monitor and evaluate their learning — perform better academically (de Boer et al., 2018). To improve your grades, it helps to figure out what you don’t know. Self-testing can help.

Testing effect. Many students assume that the way to cement new learning is to reread the material. What helps more — and what this book therefore encourages — is repeated self-testing and rehearsal of previously studied material. As we noted in Module 2.4, memory researchers call this the testing effect (Roediger & Karpicke, 2006). In one study, English-speaking students who had been tested repeatedly recalled the meaning of 20 previously learned Lithuanian words better than did students who had spent the same time restudying the 20 words (Ariel & Karpicke, 2018). Repetitive testing’s rewards also make it reinforcing: Students who used repetitive testing once found that it helped, and were more likely to use it later when learning new material. More than 200 studies confirm that frequent quizzing and self-testing boost students’ retention (Yang et al., 2021).

Interleaving. Mixing your study of psychology with your study of other subjects boosts long-term retention and protects against overconfidence (Kornell & Bjork, 2008; Taylor & Rohrer, 2010). Interleaving boosts learning by allowing us extra retrieval practice — as we switch between topics of study.

interleaving
a retrieval practice strategy that involves mixing the study of different topics.

AP® Science Practice

871

Check Your Understanding

Examine the Concept

  • Explain priming.
  • When we are tested immediately after viewing a list of words, we tend to recall the first and last items best, which is known as the ______________ effect.
  • Explain the benefits of interleaving.

Apply the Concept

  • What sort of mood have you been in lately? Explain how your mood has colored your memories, perceptions, and expectations.
  • Explain why practicing retrieval improves memory.

Answers to the Examine the Concept questions can be found in Appendix C at the end of the book.

Module 2.6 REVIEW

2.6-1 How do external cues, internal emotions, and order of appearance influence memory retrieval?

  • External cues activate associations that help us retrieve memories; this process may occur without our awareness, as it does in priming.
  • The encoding specificity principle is the idea that cues and contexts specific to a particular memory will be most effective in helping us recall it.
872
  • Returning to the same physical context or emotional state (mood congruency) in which we formed a memory can help us retrieve it.
  • The serial position effect is our tendency to recall best the last items (which may still be in working memory) and the first items (which we’ve spent more time rehearsing) in a list.

2.6-2 How do retrieval practice strategies, such as the testing effect, interleaving, and metacognition, support memory retrieval?

  • Through metacognition — tracking our understanding — we can figure out what we don’t know and use that information to improve our learning and, later, our memory retrieval.
  • The testing effect shows that repeated self-testing and retrieval practice work to improve our retention.
  • We will learn and remember better if we interleave our study of psychology with our studies of other topics.

AP® Practice Multiple Choice Questions

873

1. John has noticed that he does better on his chemistry exams when he takes them in the same seat in which he sits during class than when he sits in a different seat for exams. Assuming that John is properly prepared for exams, what psychological concept best explains the difference in his scores?

a. Recall

b. Context-dependent memory

c. Explicit memory

d. The serial position effect

2. Which of the following is an example of the serial position effect?

a. Remembering the most important assignment you have to complete for school tomorrow

b. Remembering the skills you learned early in life, such as walking

c. Remembering the beginning and end of your grocery list but not the items in the middle

d. Remembering the names of co-workers whom you met over lunch at your new job

Use the following graph to answer questions 3 and 4.

874
0 20 40 60 80 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 Position in list Percent recall primacy recency

3. What psychological concept is depicted in the graph?

a. Recency effect

b. Mood-congruent memory

c. Encoding specificity principle

d. Primacy effect

875

4. Which of the following statements accurately describes the data depicted in the graph?

a. The data in the graph represent qualitative data.

b. The data in the graph represent standard deviations.

c. The data in the graph represent quantitative data.

d. The data in the graph represent ranges.

876

5. Antonia is testing herself in preparation for her upcoming psychology test. She is aware of the value of the testing effect. Which other retrieval practice strategy is she employing by way of her self-testing?

a. Metacognition

b. Interleaving

c. Mood-congruent

d. Priming

6. Gabe has tests next week in his biology and psychology classes, and he knows that mixing his study of the two topics — shifting from biology to psychology and back — is an effective way to improve retention. What’s the name of the technique described here?

a. Metacognition

b. Interleaving

c. Mood-congruent

d. Priming

7. Dani is at a meeting where everyone goes around the table and introduces themselves. By the end, Dani can only remember the names of the last two people who introduced themselves. This is an example of which concept?

877

a. Framing

b. Mental set

c. Recency effect

d. Primacy effect

8. Which of the following involves accessing memory through recognition?

a. An oral presentation

b. An essay question

c. A fill-in-the-blank question

d. A multiple choice question

877