Today we are leveling up your commentary game: you get the claim, you bring the receipts from Eighner, then you do the thinking that connects them. Evidence shows. Commentary thinks.

Read through the presentation and be ready to complete the activity below.

Commentary Lab: On Dumpster Diving

The claim and the evidence are given. Your job is the thinking. Everything happens inside Snorkl.

1. Your Materials

The Claim · do not change it

Eighner argues that scavenging is a sound and honorable way of life, a form of self-reliance that teaches a person what things are really worth.

Quotation 1 · Supports

“I think of scavenging as a modern form of self-reliance.”

This quotation backs the claim.

Quotation 2 · Pushes back

“Dumpster diving has serious drawbacks as a way of life.”

This quotation complicates the claim.

Source: Lars Eighner, “On Dumpster Diving”

2. What You Turn In (all in Snorkl)

Part 14 written commentaries
+
Part 21 audio, 60+ seconds

3. Part 1: The Four Moves

Ratio 1:2. One quotation, two commentaries. A = unpack the evidence. B = turn it toward the claim.

Quotation 1

“…a modern form of self-reliance.”

➜
1A
Unpack

What does this evidence really reveal about Eighner, his values, or the people he argues against? Interpretation only.

➜
1B
Turn

Why does that revelation matter for the claim?

Open with: “That matters because…” / “More importantly…” / “This is why…”
Quotation 2

“…serious drawbacks as a way of life.”

➜
2A
Unpack

Same job as 1A: what does this evidence really reveal?

➜
2B
Qualify

Quotation 2 pushes back, so bend the claim without breaking it.

Open with: “Yet…” / “Even so…” / “Still…”
1A 1B 2A 2BLabel every commentary
~2sentences per commentary
55+words total across all four

4. Three Rules

✖ No Summary

Commentary is not summary. Do not retell what Eighner said.

✖ No Filler

If a sentence could be pasted after a different quotation and still make sense, it is filler. Rewrite it.

✖ Delete Test

If deleting your commentary changes nothing, it failed.

5. Part 2: Audio Reflection

Record inside Snorkl. At least 60 seconds. Explain why you wrote your commentary the way you did. Answer all three, in order:

1

Which commentary does which job? Walk through 1A, 1B, 2A, 2B and say what each one is trying to do.

2

Where did you attempt a sophistication move? (name a tension, qualify the claim, or widen the stakes beyond Eighner) Read that sentence out loud and explain the move.

3

Which commentary is your weakest, and why? Is it summary in disguise, does it drift off the claim, or does it repeat its partner commentary in new words?

6. Before You Submit

  • Four commentaries labeled 1A, 1B, 2A, 2B
  • 1B opens with a turn signal
  • 2B opens with a qualifying signal
  • About two sentences each, 55+ words total
  • No summary, no filler, passes the Delete Test
  • Audio recorded in Snorkl, 60+ seconds, all three questions in order
Free-Response Question 3

AP Lang Argument Rubric (6 points)

This is the official College Board scoring rubric for the AP English Language and Composition Argument essay. In this commentary lab, the thinking you write after the evidence is scored in Row B (Evidence and Commentary). The sophistication moves you attempt are scored in Row C (Sophistication).

0–1Row A · Thesis
0–4Row B · Evidence and Commentary
0–1Row C · Sophistication
Row A

Thesis

0–1 point

0 points

For any of the following:

  • There is no defensible thesis.
  • The intended thesis only restates the prompt.
  • The intended thesis provides a summary of the issue with no apparent or coherent claim.
  • There is a thesis, but it does not respond to the prompt.

Responses that do not earn this point

  • Only restate the prompt.
  • Do not take a position, or the position is vague or must be inferred.
  • State an obvious fact rather than making a claim that requires a defense.

What this looks like: The sentence does not actually take a stand on the prompt. It restates the prompt, stays vague, or states an obvious fact.

1 point

Responds to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.

Responses that earn this point

  • Respond to the prompt rather than restate or rephrase the prompt, and the thesis clearly takes a position rather than just stating that there are pros/cons.

What this looks like: You clearly take a defensible position that answers the prompt — not merely that there are two sides.

Additional notes

  • The thesis may be more than one sentence, provided the sentences are in close proximity.
  • The thesis may be anywhere within the response.
  • The thesis may establish a line of reasoning that structures the essay, but it needn’t do so to earn the thesis point.
  • A thesis that meets the criteria can be awarded the point whether or not the rest of the response successfully supports that line of reasoning.
Row B

Evidence and Commentary

0–4 points

0 points

Simply restates thesis (if present), repeats provided information, or offers information irrelevant to the prompt.

Typical responses that earn 0 points

  • Are incoherent or do not address the prompt.
  • May be just opinion with no evidence or evidence that is irrelevant.

What this looks like: There is no usable evidence — only a restated thesis, leftover prompt language, off-topic material, or unsupported opinion.

1 point

Evidence Provides evidence that is mostly general.
Commentary Summarizes the evidence but does not explain how the evidence supports the argument.

Typical responses that earn 1 point

  • Tend to focus on summary of evidence rather than specific details.

What this looks like: The evidence stays general, and the writing mostly retells it instead of explaining how it supports the argument. In this lab, that is commentary that summarizes Eighner.

2 points

Evidence Provides some specific, relevant evidence.
Commentary Explains how some of the evidence relates to the student’s argument, but no line of reasoning is established, or the line of reasoning is faulty.

Typical responses that earn 2 points

  • Consist of a mix of specific evidence and broad generalities.
  • May contain some simplistic, inaccurate, or repetitive explanations that don’t strengthen the argument.
  • May make one point well but either do not make multiple supporting claims or do not adequately support more than one claim.
  • Do not explain the connections or progression between the student’s claims, so a line of reasoning is not clearly established.

What this looks like: Some evidence is specific, and some of it is explained, but the essay does not build a clear, working line of reasoning from claim to claim.

3 points

Evidence Provides specific evidence to support all claims in a line of reasoning.
Commentary Explains how some of the evidence supports a line of reasoning.

Typical responses that earn 3 points

  • Uniformly offer evidence to support claims.
  • Focus on the importance of specific details to build an argument.
  • Organize an argument as a line of reasoning composed of multiple supporting claims.
  • Commentary may fail to integrate some evidence or fail to support a key claim.

What this looks like: Specific evidence supports the claims in a line of reasoning, but the commentary only explains some of that evidence — a key claim may still be thin.

4 points

Evidence Provides specific evidence to support all claims in a line of reasoning.
Commentary Consistently explains how the evidence supports a line of reasoning.

Typical responses that earn 4 points

  • Uniformly offer evidence to support claims.
  • Focus on the importance of specific details to build an argument.
  • Organize and support an argument as a line of reasoning composed of multiple supporting claims, each with adequate evidence that is clearly explained.

What this looks like: Specific evidence supports every claim, and the commentary consistently explains how that evidence builds the line of reasoning — the “thinking,” not a retelling of the quotation.

Additional note. Writing that suffers from grammatical and/or mechanical errors that interfere with communication cannot earn the fourth point in this row.
Row C

Sophistication

0–1 point

0 points

Does not meet the criteria for one point.

Responses that do not earn this point

  • Attempt to contextualize their argument, but such attempts consist predominantly of sweeping generalizations (“In a world where…” OR “Since the beginning of time…”).
  • Only hint at or suggest other arguments (“While some may argue that…” OR “Some people say…”).
  • Use complicated or complex sentences or language that is ineffective because it does not enhance the argument.

What this looks like: A broad generalization, a brief hint at another view, or ornate sentences that do not actually strengthen the argument.

1 point

Demonstrates sophistication of thought and/or a complex understanding of the rhetorical situation.

What this looks like: The sophistication is woven through the argument itself — not a single stylish sentence dropped in at the end.

Responses that earn this point may demonstrate sophistication of thought and/or a complex understanding of the rhetorical situation by doing any of the following

  1. Crafting a nuanced argument by consistently identifying and exploring complexities or tensions.
  2. Articulating the implications or limitations of an argument (either the student’s argument or an argument related to the prompt) by situating it within a broader context.
  3. Making effective rhetorical choices that consistently strengthen the force and impact of the student’s argument.
  4. Employing a style that is consistently vivid and persuasive.
Additional note. This point should be awarded only if the sophistication of thought or complex understanding is part of the student’s argument, not merely a phrase or reference.

Official scoring criteria from the College Board AP English Language and Composition Argument essay (Free-Response Question 3) scoring rubric, 6 points. The “What this looks like” lines are plain-language guides for this lab; they are not College Board language.